Choosing Between Orthotics and Physical Therapy

Foot, ankle, and leg pain can take a toll, not just physically, but on your daily routine, your work, and even your mood. When discomfort keeps showing up, it’s natural to wonder where to start. Should you try orthotics first? Is physical therapy the better option? Or do you actually need a combination of the two?

Both approaches can be incredibly helpful, but they work in different ways. Understanding what each one does, and when it’s most effective, can make the decision feel much less overwhelming.

How Orthotics Help With Pain and Mobility

Orthotics are designed to support the way your feet move, helping your body stay aligned and reducing strain on your joints. When your feet aren’t absorbing shock properly or your arches aren’t working as they should, the rest of your body often has to compensate. That can lead to aching heels, sore knees, tight calves, and even lower-back discomfort.

Custom orthotics step in by giving your feet a more stable, balanced foundation. They can help:

• Improve alignment from the feet upward
• Reduce pressure on sensitive areas like the heels and arches
• Support flat feet or high arches
• Ease discomfort from long hours of standing or walking
• Add stability on hard winter surfaces
• Promote more movement throughout the day

People often notice that with the right pair of orthotics, everyday activities, walking, working, running errands, feel a little easier. If your pain tends to flare up after long periods on your feet or improves when you switch to more supportive footwear, orthotics may be a strong first step toward better comfort.

When Physical Therapy Is the Better Choice

Orthotics focus on supporting the structure of your feet, physical therapy focuses on how your body moves. Many types of foot and leg pain come from tight muscles, weakness, or movement patterns that put extra strain on certain areas. In these cases, improving mobility and strengthening key muscles can make a noticeable difference.

Physical therapy may be the better place to start if your pain:

• Changes depending on activity or movement
• Improves when you stretch or warm up
• Feels connected to muscle tightness or weakness
• Comes on after exercise or repetitive tasks
• Limits your range of motion in the ankles, knees, or hips

A therapist may use a combination of exercises, stretching, balance training, and gait correction to help restore healthier movement patterns. These techniques can relieve discomfort, support tissue recovery, and help prevent the same issues from returning.

If you find your pain eases when you move around, or if certain muscles feel tight, strained, or overworked, physical therapy may offer the strength and mobility support your body needs.

How to Decide … Orthotics or Physical Therapy?

It’s completely normal to feel unsure about where to begin, both orthotics and physical therapy offer valuable benefits, and many people ultimately use a combination of the two. A helpful way to decide is to pay attention to the type of discomfort you’re experiencing and what seems to trigger or relieve it.

Orthotics may be more helpful if your pain:

• Appears after standing or walking for long periods
• Improves when you wear supportive shoes
• Is linked to flat feet, high arches, or alignment issues
• Feels worse on hard floors or uneven winter surfaces
• Is centered around the heels, arches, or balls of the feet

Orthotics create a stable foundation, reducing stress on joints and helping your feet move more efficiently. They shine when structural support or alignment is the main issue.

Physical therapy may be more helpful if your pain:

• Changes depending on movement or activity
• Improves with stretching, heat, or mobility work
• Feels muscular rather than “impact” based
• Started after an injury, exercise change, or overuse
• Comes with stiffness or reduced range of motion

Physical therapy focuses on strength, flexibility, and proper mechanics. It’s ideal when muscles and joints need training, not just support.

For many people, the best results come from using both approaches together, orthotics to support the structure of the feet, and physical therapy to strengthen the muscles that guide your movement. Working hand-in-hand, they can help reduce pain and improve mobility.

Shockwave Therapy as a Treatment Option

Even with proper support and improved movement, some types of pain can be stubborn. When discomfort has lingered for weeks or months, or keeps coming back despite your best efforts, you may benefit from an additional therapeutic option.

Radial Shockwave Therapy is a non-invasive treatment that uses controlled pulses to stimulate circulation and encourage the body’s natural healing response. It’s often recommended when pain is linked to tight or irritated soft tissue that hasn’t responded fully to stretching, strengthening, or footwear changes.

It may be especially helpful for:

• Persistent heel or arch pain
• Early stages of plantar fasciitis
• Achilles tendon discomfort
• Chronic tightness in the calves or lower legs
• Pain that improves temporarily but keeps returning

Shockwave therapy doesn’t replace orthotics or physical therapy, instead, it works alongside them. Orthotics provide structural support, physical therapy improves movement and strength, and shockwave therapy helps address stubborn areas of tension or irritation that won’t calm down on their own.

For people who feel like they’ve “tried everything,” this combination can offer meaningful progress and help reduce daily discomfort.

Benefits of Getting New Orthotics During Winter

Winter may not be the season most people associate with foot care, but it’s actually one of the most practical times to update or invest in new orthotics. Cold weather changes how we move, icy sidewalks, heavier footwear, and extra time spent indoors on hard surfaces all put added stress on the feet and lower legs.

Because activity levels often shift in winter, many people start noticing discomfort they’ve been able to ignore during the warmer months. Soreness in the arches, morning heel pain, tired legs, or pressure along the knees often becomes more noticeable this time of year.

Getting new orthotics in winter offers a few advantages:

• You break them in during a quieter season, before spring activities increase.
• Your body has time to adjust, making the transition smoother.
• Support matters more on slippery or uneven surfaces, helping improve stability and confidence in winter conditions.
• Indoor flooring can be hard on the feet, and proper support can make daily routines feel more comfortable.

Winter becomes a natural reset point, an opportunity to give your feet the support they need before the busier, more active months return. A well-fitted pair of orthotics can make a noticeable difference not just in comfort, but in how you move through the season.

Need help figuring out what's causing your foot or leg pain? Book an appointment with our Certified Chiropodist for a personalized assessment.

Book Appointment

Choosing the Right Approach for Your Feet

Foot and leg pain can show up for all kinds of reasons, sometimes structural, sometimes muscular, and sometimes because winter changes how we move. It’s completely normal to feel unsure about which option will help you most. A Foot Assessment can make things clearer by looking at how your feet function, how you walk, and which areas may need support, strength, or a bit of extra care.

When a specialist evaluates your movement and alignment, it becomes much easier to see whether orthotics, physical therapy, shockwave therapy, or a combination of them fits your needs. Every person’s situation is different, and the right plan is usually the one that blends comfort, support, and movement in a way that feels natural for your body.